The Fat Over Lean Rule in Oil Painting: The Complete Guide

The Fat Over Lean Rule in Oil Painting: The Complete Guide

A Complete Guide for Beginners and Intermediate Painters

If you've ever had an oil painting crack, peel, or fail to dry properly, there's a good chance you've fallen foul of one of the most important rules in oil painting: the fat over lean principle. Understanding this rule — and following it — is the difference between artwork that lasts for centuries and one that starts to deteriorate within years.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll walk you through everything you need to know about painting fat over lean, why it matters, how to apply it in practice, and what the experts say. Whether you're brand new to oils or looking to tighten up your technique, read on.

What Does 'Fat Over Lean' Mean?

The fat over lean rule — is a fundamental principle of oil painting technique. In simple terms, it means that each successive layer of paint you apply should contain more oil than the one beneath it.

'Lean' paint contains little or no added oil, typically mixed only with a solvent such as turpentine or odourless mineral spirits. 'Fat' paint contains more oil — either from the paint itself (some pigments are naturally oil-rich) or from additional linseed, stand, or poppy oil added to the mix.

"Fat over lean is the most important technical rule in oil painting. Ignoring it is the most common cause of paint film failure in both student and professional work." — Michael Harding, renowned oil paint maker and restorer

The reason this matters comes down to drying rates and flexibility. Lean paint (with less oil) dries faster and forms a more rigid film. Fat paint (with more oil) dries more slowly and remains more flexible. If you apply a fast-drying, rigid layer on top of a slow-drying, flexible one, the top layer will crack as the bottom layer continues to move and dry beneath it.

The Science Behind It: Why Does It Matter?

Oil paint doesn't dry by evaporation the way watercolour or acrylic does. It dries through a process called oxidation, in which the oil molecules absorb oxygen from the air and cross-link to form a tough, flexible film. This process takes time — from days to weeks to months — and different oils and different amounts of oil dry at different rates.

The Problem with Fat Under Lean

When you apply a lean (oil-poor) layer over a fat (oil-rich) layer that hasn't fully dried, several problems can occur over time. The lean layer is more rigid, so as the fat layer beneath continues to dry and contract, the rigid surface layer can't accommodate the movement — it cracks. This is the classic 'alligator' or 'crocodile' cracking pattern you sometimes see on old paintings that weren't made correctly.

Conversely, when you paint fat over lean correctly, each successive layer is more flexible than the one beneath. The entire paint film can move together as a unit without stressing any single layer, and the painting remains stable and intact — potentially for hundreds of years.

What the Experts Say

This is not a new idea. The masters of the Renaissance understood it intuitively, even if they didn't articulate it in quite these terms.

"The Flemish masters achieved their extraordinary luminosity by building up from lean imprimatura layers through to rich, oily glazes. The technical discipline was inseparable from the aesthetic result." — Ralph Mayer, The Artist's Handbook of Materials and Techniques

Modern conservators and paint chemists have validated this practice through scientific study. Research into historic paintings that have survived in excellent condition consistently shows adherence to fat over lean layer construction.

How to Apply the Fat Over Lean Rule in Practice

Step 1: Your Ground and Imprimatura (Very Lean)

Start with a well-prepared, primed canvas or board. If you apply an imprimatura (a thin, toned ground layer), this should be extremely lean — paint thinned heavily with solvent and no added oil whatsoever. Let this dry completely before proceeding.

A traditional approach is to tone your canvas with a thin wash of burnt sienna or raw umber thinned with turpentine or odourless mineral spirit. This establishes a mid-tone to work against and is as lean as you can get.

Step 2: The Lay-In or Block-In (Lean)

Your initial drawing-in and blocking of main shapes and values should still be quite lean. Use paint thinned with a small amount of solvent, or use it straight from the tube without adding oils. Many painters use this stage to establish composition, value structure, and colour temperature.

This layer should be kept thin and relatively transparent. You're not trying to achieve the final effect yet — you're building a foundation.

Step 3: Middle Layers (Medium)

As you build up subsequent layers, begin introducing a small amount of oil. A classic painting medium for this stage is a 1:1 mixture of linseed oil and turpentine (or odourless mineral spirit). This gives you some added flexibility and blendability without going overboard on oil content.

You can also use a proprietary painting medium at this stage. Products like Liquin Original (Winsor & Newton) or Galkyd (Gamblin) are popular because they speed drying while adding appropriate flexibility.

Step 4: Upper Layers and Glazes (Fat)

Your final layers, scumbles, and glazes should be the most oil-rich. Oil-heavy glazes — thin, transparent layers of colour mixed with a generous amount of linseed or stand oil — sit beautifully over leaner underlayers and create luminous depth.

At this stage, some painters use stand oil or sun-thickened oil, which produces a beautiful enamel-like surface and has excellent archival qualities. These are among the richest, 'fattest' mediums available.

"Think of each layer as a different-speed motorway lane. The lean layers are the fast lane — they dry quickly and set firm. The fat layers are the slow lane. Always let the fast lane pass first, then add the slow lane on top — never the other way round." — Master painter and tutor Charles Reid

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Mistake 1: Adding Too Much Oil Too Soon

Many beginners, frustrated that their paint is stiff and hard to blend, reach for the linseed oil bottle in the very first session. Resist this temptation. Instead, thin your paint with solvent if needed, or use a medium sparingly. Save the oil for your later layers.

Mistake 2: Not Allowing Layers to Dry

Alla prima (wet-into-wet) painting in a single session is perfectly valid — in this case the fat over lean rule applies within the wet paint, since you're not building up dried layers. But if you're working in multiple sessions, each layer must be dry to the touch (and ideally fully through-dried) before adding the next. Rushing this is a common cause of problems.

Mistake 3: Using the Wrong Mediums

Some mediums, particularly those based on varnish resins, can cause problems when used in early layers. Stick to simple, well-tested mediums: solvent alone for lean layers, linseed or alkyd mediums for middle and upper layers.

Mistake 4: Over-Oiling

Even in your fattest layers, there's a limit. Excessively oil-rich paint is prone to yellowing, wrinkling, and other problems. A good rule of thumb is to add no more than one part oil to every two or three parts paint.

Choosing the Right Oils and Mediums

Not all oils behave the same way, and choosing the right one for each stage of your painting is important.

Linseed Oil

The most widely used oil in oil painting. Cold-pressed linseed oil is considered the best for most purposes — it dries reasonably fast and has good film strength. Refined linseed oil is paler and slower drying. Stand oil is heat-polymerised linseed oil that produces a wonderfully smooth, enamel-like surface and is excellent for glazing and final layers.

Poppy Oil

Paler than linseed and less prone to yellowing, poppy oil is often used with whites and pale colours. However, it dries significantly more slowly than linseed oil and can cause adhesion problems if used in lower layers. Best reserved for upper layers and glazes.

Walnut Oil

A traditional Renaissance medium that is paler than linseed and less prone to yellowing. It dries at a moderate rate and is an excellent all-round oil for middle and upper layers.

Alkyd Mediums

Modern alkyd-based mediums such as Liquin (Winsor & Newton) are synthetic alkyd resins that dramatically speed up drying time while still maintaining the fat over lean structure. They're particularly useful for painters who want to work in multiple sessions without long waits between layers.

Fat Over Lean in Different Painting Styles

Alla Prima (Wet-Into-Wet)

In alla prima painting — completing a work in one session while the paint is still wet — the fat over lean principle still applies, but in a more fluid way. You should generally work your initial marks leaner (less oil, more solvent) and your blending and final touches richer. The key is that you're not laying fat paint into lean wet paint in a way that creates a distinct problematic interface.

Classical Layering Techniques

Traditional multi-layer approaches such as the Flemish technique or the indirect method depend heavily on fat over lean discipline. These methods typically involve an underpainting in monochrome (lean), colour modelling in semi-transparent layers (medium), and final glazes (fat). The beauty and depth of old master paintings is largely a result of this careful layering.

Impasto Painting

Thick, impasto work is generally applied in upper layers, which should indeed be oil-rich and fat. Applying heavy impasto in early layers is a technical error — not only does it violate the fat over lean principle, but it also creates a surface that's difficult to paint over and may crack as it dries.

What the Masters Taught Us

The fat over lean principle isn't a modern invention — it's a codification of practices that were understood and followed by the great painters of history.

"The materials of painting are not neutral. They have character, and working with their nature rather than against it is the foundation of lasting craftsmanship." — Jacques Maroger, The Secret Formulas and Techniques of the Masters

Jan van Eyck, widely regarded as the father of oil painting, used carefully constructed fat over lean layering to achieve the extraordinary luminosity of works like the Ghent Altarpiece. Rembrandt's characteristic warm, glowing darks were achieved through rich, oily glazes applied over leaner underlayers. Vermeer's delicate light effects relied on the same principle.

Modern technical analysis of historic paintings — including X-ray and infrared examination — confirms that the greatest works of the Western tradition were built on exactly these principles.

Quick Reference: Fat Over Lean at a Glance

Here's a simple framework to keep in mind as you paint:

• Layer 1 — Ground/Imprimatura: Solvent only, no oil. Very lean.
• Layer 2 — Block-in/Lay-in: Solvent, minimal or no oil. Lean.
• Layer 3 — Middle layers: Small amount of linseed oil or alkyd medium. Medium.
• Layer 4 — Upper layers and detail: More oil or medium. Medium-fat.
• Layer 5 — Glazes and final touches: Generous oil (stand oil, linseed). Fat.

Always ensure each layer is dry before applying the next (unless working wet-into-wet in a single session). When in doubt, leave it longer. Patience is perhaps the most important tool in the oil painter's kit.

Get Everything You Need at Craft & Canvas

Whether you're just starting out or looking to refine your technique, having the right materials makes all the difference. At Craft & Canvas, we stock a carefully curated range of oil paints, mediums, and studio essentials to support your painting practice at every level.

From quality linseed oils and alkyd mediums to a full range of artist-grade oil paints in both student and professional grades, you'll find everything you need to paint correctly and confidently. Our friendly team are passionate about art and always happy to offer advice.

Browse our full range of oil painting supplies at www.craftandcanvas.co.uk — and give your paintings the solid technical foundation they deserve.

Happy painting!

Further Reading & References

Ralph Mayer — The Artist's Handbook of Materials and Techniques (Viking Press)

Jacques Maroger — The Secret Formulas and Techniques of the Masters (Borden Publishing)

Mark David Gottsegen — The Painter's Handbook (Watson-Guptill Publications)

Michael Harding — Technical Notes on Oil Painting (michaelharding.co.uk)

Gamblin Artists Colors — Technical Information Bulletins (gamblincolors.com)

Winsor & Newton — Oil Colour Technical Guide (winsornewton.com)

© Craft & Canvas | www.craftandcanvas.co.uk